Summer vs. Winter Tree Removal in Edmonton: What You Need to Know

Reading time: 6 minutes

The trees in your Edmonton yard are the backbone of its charm. Yet even these mighty trees have their off days, or rather, off-seasons.

Whether it’s a diseased oak that cannot be saved or a tree threatening to collapse after a snowstorm, sometimes, a tree's gotta go.

Picking the perfect season isn't as easy as just marking a date on your calendar. With Edmonton going from sizzling summers to freezing winters, each season has its pros and cons for tree removal.

Green Drop worker using machinery to move cut trees

Edmonton’s Seasons and Its Impact on Trees

Your trees live in extremes. Edmonton’s seasonal swings can take a toll on their health. Spring and summer showcase your trees in all their glory—full and green, creating cool, shady retreats.

Then winter arrives to take away the summer disguise. You see weaknesses and damage your tree has endured and sometimes inflicted, possibly on your property. When this happens, tree removal may be the only choice for you.

Understanding how Edmonton's harsh seasons affect your trees' health is crucial for deciding the optimal timing for tree removal. It’s about you choosing a time that minimizes the impact on your yard and the tree’s surroundings.

Pros and Cons of Summer Tree Removal

cut trees and a chainsaw on a piece of metal

Pro: Accessibility To Better Working Conditions

One of the clear advantages of opting for tree removal during the summer is ease of access. With the ground firm and dry, your arborists can manoeuvre equipment close to the tree. The risk of the equipment sinking into mud or snow is negligible.

Moreover, the extended daylight hours are helpful for both homeowners and tree removal teams. Longer days mean work can continue for hours, ensuring a quicker project turnaround. This is particularly beneficial for large-scale removals or when multiple trees on a property need attention.

Con: The Summer Strains

However, summer tree removal isn't without its challenges. The blooming growth around the tree means it’s under threat. There are chances of collateral damage, from the delicate flowerbeds underfoot to the nearby shrubs and plants.

Professional tree removal services tackle these problems with strategic planning and precision. We use protective barriers and careful equipment routing to minimize impact, ensuring your yard's beauty remains intact.

Our skilled arborists assess the site and execute the removal, preserving the surrounding greenery. We’ll employ techniques like sectional dismantling to reduce the operation footprint.

The Cold, Hard Facts of Winter Tree Removal

Tree removal machinery used by Green Drop

Pro: Tree Dormancy

Winter presents a unique opportunity for tree removal with one major benefit: since trees are dormant and without leaves in winter, their structure is fully exposed. This allows arborists to make precise cuts and better decisions on how best to remove the tree.

Additionally, the frozen ground helps preserve the surrounding ecosystem. The hard soil minimizes damage to the landscape around the tree, as heavy equipment is less likely to leave deep imprints or disturb the soil.

Con: Tough for Removal Teams

Yet, winter tree removal has its challenges. The very cold that freezes the ground and makes the trees dormant can also make working conditions harsh for tree removal crews. They can make access to the tree difficult, leading to delays.

Despite these challenges, winter tree removal is the better option. The trees are dormant and lighter, making the whole process more efficient and even safer.

Spring and Fall Considerations for Tree Removal

Green Drop worker removing a piece of tree using a lift

While the extremes of summer heat and winter cold have advantages for tree removal, spring and fall often hit the sweet spot. These milder months blend some of the best aspects of the year's more intense seasons, offering a balanced approach.

Spring, with its gradually warming weather, brings trees back from dormancy, but often before they've fully leafed out. This semi-dormant state means arborists can easily assess a tree's structure. The ground is also usually thawed but not as soft as it will be in peak summer.

Fall offers a similar advantage. As the leaves begin to turn and drop, the visibility of the tree's structure improves, making it easier for arborists to plan and execute removal. The ground, hardened by the summer's heat, supports equipment better than the softer soils of spring. Plus, the cooler temperatures make for more comfortable conditions for both the crew and the tree.

The Verdict: When Is the Best Time To Remove a Tree?

So, now that you know about the seasonal consideration for tree removal, how do you decide? Well, your decision cannot be solely based on weather and convenience. It depends more on the tree's health and the potential safety risks of not removing it.

This is where you need more than a keen eye and a good guess. Professional arborists can spot clues that spell trouble and give you the lowdown on whether your tree is in the clear or on borrowed time. They take the guesswork out of the equation, blending science with savvy to guide you toward the best decision for your tree.

Green Drop worker standing next to a tree holding a piece of paper

The truth is it doesn’t really matter which season you remove your tree. Emergencies happen, and it doesn’t really factor into the weather. If you can wait and tree removal isn’t an emergency, the best time for tree removal would be early winter and spring, mainly because these are dormant months.

On the other hand, if you can’t wait and a tree has really become a hazard, it all comes down to the tree removal company you’re working with. By working with ISA-certified arborists who are experienced in working in different conditions, you can ensure a smooth removal process.

The Legalities of Removing a Tree in Edmonton

Unfortunately, tree removal in Edmonton involves more than just your decision. You also need to understand and adhere to specific legal requirements.

You might require a permit when dealing with significant trees on public property or in some protected regions. However, for most residential trees, you don’t currently require city permission. That said, it's always wise to check the latest municipal guidelines online or contact city officials to confirm, as regulations can change.

If you're part of a homeowners' association or live in a designated historical area, additional rules may apply. In these cases, approval might be required to ensure the area's character and ecological balance are maintained.

Trees straddling property lines or shared with neighbours can also complicate removal plans. In such instances, communication is key. Before taking any action, talk to them about your concerns and intentions. If disagreements arise, mediation services may help reach a resolution that satisfies both parties.

Post-Removal Considerations

After a tree removal, you're left with a blank canvas in your yard. It’s an opportunity to rethink and rejuvenate your outdoor space. Here are some ideas to transform that empty spot into something special:

  • Create a Garden Bed. Where a tree once stood, the soil is often very fertile. Consider planting a flowerbed or a vegetable garden. This area can become a colourful, vibrant spot that attracts pollinators or provides fresh produce for your table.
  • Install a Hardscape Feature. This could be the perfect place for a new patio, fire pit, or water feature. These elements add a new dimension to your landscaping, providing focal points that draw the eye and spaces for relaxation and entertainment.
  • Lawn Expansion. If you prefer a seamless green expanse, fill in the area with matching sod or seed. This can help maintain a uniform look across your yard while providing extra play or relaxation space.
Green Drop workers cutting and removing trees

Turn to The Tree Removal Experts in Edmonton

As we've examined the pros and cons of summer vs. winter tree removal, it’s clear that timing isn’t everything, but expert advice is.

Before you go out on a limb, consult the tree-mendous expertise of our arborists. Book a free assessment with Green Drop, and let our arborists help you fall in love with your landscape all over again.

Don’t wait until the branches fall off. Get professional tree removal services and branch out toward a safer, more beautiful yard.

Schedule Your Free Tree Removal Assessment